Mitch's Pizza and Subs is one of those Blairsville restaurants that has been around long enough that locals have their usual order memorized. It sits on Highway 76 heading toward Young Harris, in a standalone building that does not look like much from the outside but is consistently busy during meal times.
The pizza here is hand-tossed, cooked in a deck oven, and available by the slice during lunch hours. The crust is thinner than a standard hand-tossed but not cracker-thin — a middle ground that works well for both dine-in and takeout. Toppings are generous without being excessive, and the sauce has a noticeable herb profile that sets it apart from the chain competition.
Beyond pizza, Mitch's does a solid Italian sub and a handful of pasta dishes. The menu is not enormous, but everything on it is made to order and the kitchen staff has been doing this long enough that consistency is not an issue.
The dining room is casual, booths and tables, nothing fancy. Most of the business is takeout, especially on weekend evenings. Call your order in rather than relying on a website — they answer the phone and will have your food ready when you arrive.